Re: Street grid restoration and the arena being "finished"

Written by Susan Mannella on .

In response to the June 9 editorial "Reality Trumps Fantasy: Lack of a Developer Says It All on Keeping the Arena": Respectfully, it appears that the editors of the Post-Gazette continue to be uninformed about the flexibility inherent in historic preservation. As I outlined in a letter to the PG on Dec. 9 ("Preserving the Arena"), the vast majority of preservation falls under the approach of "rehabilitation," defined as "the act or process of making possible a compatible use for a property through repair, alterations and additions while preserving those portions or features which convey its historical, cultural or architectural values."

Think Heinz Lofts (condos, not ketchup); the Freight House Shops at Station Square (retail and restaurants, not rail cars); the History Center (cool exhibits, but no longer any ice). You get the picture. Preservation allows for considerable modification and changes in use.

As an arena, I might concede that the Igloo is "outmoded." However, as a repurposed civic center, it is far from "finished" — unless the Post-Gazette's apparent standard of "no developer has stepped forward" is given any merit. But by that argument, the Penguins' plan is equal fantasy.

Lastly, can this paper please help to once-and-for-all stop the disingenuous assertion that the Pens' development plan "restores the street grid of the lower Hill District"? You are repeating specious claims, which had they been investigated, would show that the street grid within the 28 acres of the Lower Hill contained approximately 11,340 linear feet of named thoroughfares containing buildings with street addresses. The UDA plan proposes approximately 4,810 linear feet of streets, or roughly 42 percent. Few of these would be located where original streets were located because of the large, nontraditional block sizes being proposed — far from "restoring the grid."


Preservation Planner

Squirrel Hill

Join the conversation:

To report inappropriate comments, abuse and/or repeat offenders, please send an email to and include a link to the article and a copy of the comment. Your report will be reviewed in a timely manner. Thank you.